Gone Fishin’ Sport Fishing Charters Customer Reviews

Name: Gone Fishin’ Sport Fishing Charters
Brand: Gone Fishin’ Sport Fishing Charters
Rating: 5 (39 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 39
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Mark Elliott consistently puts his clients on fish from the moment they reach the fishing grounds until it's time to head back. His expertise shines through as he targets diverse species including Dorado, Dolphinfish, False Albacore, Bluefish, Striped Bass, Flounder, and even Tiger Sharks. Mark knows all the productive spots and adapts quickly to conditions - whether trolling offshore for gamefish or switching to bay fishing when weather demands it. He expertly fillets catches at the dock and teaches bait-catching techniques at his secret spots. Mark creates memorable family experiences that turn first-time boat novices into enthusiastic repeat customers. His communication starts before the trip with detailed weather and fishing condition updates, and continues throughout with patient explanations of techniques and genuine excitement when fish are biting. The well-maintained boat provides smooth, comfortable rides, while Mark and his rotating crew of experienced first mates handle all the details from baiting hooks to cleaning fish. Families regularly return year after year, with many customers already planning their next annual trip before leaving the dock.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Expert Captain

Diverse Species

Family Friendly

Repeat Customers

Smooth Rides

Productive Spots

Patient Teaching

Annual Trips

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

Anglers enjoying fishing adventure in unknown location

One person fishing in an unknown location

Two Spanish Mackerel and Atlantic Bonito fish caught while fishing

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

OWEN HEWETSON

September 4, 2025

Trip - Fishing Charters Cape May NJ | 10 Hour Mahi Mahi Fishing on September 3, 2025

6:00 AM - 4:00 PM

Max 6 guests

Great keeping in touch in days before trip regarding weather reports and fishing conditions. Rendezvous was flawless and we were making our way out the marina bang on time. I am 64, and my two sons 31 and 33. All novices on a fishing boat. Trawling for small gamefish ? 20 to 30 ? miles out catch-and-release was our request. I let my 2 sons fish while I snapped pictures. By 8:40 a.m they had already caught enough fish that we were all smiles ! We did intend keeping count of what we caught, but lost track in one of the flurries. Guess around 25 fish mixed bag of Dorado, Dolphinfish and False Albacore. The Dolphinfish were “the dream”. Captain Mark and 1st Mate Tim spared no effort to give us a fine time. The boat was fantastic. Smooth comfortable ride there and back. When planning the trip, the boys and I spoke of “A trip of a lifetime”. Now we are talking more of an Annual Trip. Many thanks to Captain Mark and Tim. You made our dreams come true.

Was this helpful ?

Kristina Hiser

August 13, 2025

Trip - Fishing Charter Cape May NJ | 4 Hour Charter Trip on August 13, 2025

7:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Another amazing trip with the Gone Fishin crew. This is the second trip for our family & this year was even more spectacular than last year. We caught over a hundred bluefish & some Spanish Mackeral & never stopped catching fish the entire trip! The kids loved it. First mate Joe was exceptional, knowledgeable & absolutely patient & kind & never failed to cast a line or remove a hook from a fish & let the kids throw it back. Joe fileted our Spanish Mackeral, so we could take home & cook. Every minute of this trip was fantastic. Super clean boat, comfortable, air conditioning & a wonderful captain.

Was this helpful ?

Jeff Elburn Elburn

July 23, 2025

Trip - Fishing Charter Cape May NJ | 4 Hour Charter Trip on July 23, 2025

7:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Capt. Mark and his mate Joe gave our family a great day of fishing. Beginners (at best) but we were able to catch 5 sand sharks during our afternoon on the bay. Could not have been a better time. Thank you both and we will always remember this trip. Hope to come back next year!

Was this helpful ?

Craig Spring

July 18, 2025

Trip - Fishing Charters In Cape May NJ | 6 Hour Charter Trip on July 18, 2025

7:00 AM - 1:00 PM

3/4 Day Trip on July 18, 2025 • 3 adults We had an amazing experience today aboard the Gone Fishin’! Captain Mark and first mate Joe were extremely professional and proficient in every aspect. We were put on the fish right away and the action never stopped! The vessel was clean and the cabin was well appointed, with a/c to boot. 10 out of 10 for this crew and our experience. We WILL be back! Thanks again for a fantastic day! Craig, Joe & Jeff

Was this helpful ?

Joe Horton

July 16, 2025

Trip - Fishing Charter Cape May NJ | 4 Hour Charter Trip on July 16, 2025

7:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Booked with Captain Mark through the site. Had a great time. Nice boat. Very stable. Air-conditioned cabin. I’m 6’4” and I could stand to use the head no problem. Great first mate Joe. Four of us went and each caught between four or five fish. Total of 23 on a 4 hour trip. Had a great day on the water. Highly recommend.

Was this helpful ?

Will G

July 5, 2025

Trip - Fishing Charter Cape May NJ | 4 Hour Charter Trip on July 5, 2025

7:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Had a good time with Mark and Joe. They are professional and tell you all you need to know and are very helpful. They bait the hooks for you. Clean the fish and help you overall with the experience. My only issue was the water was rough so I got seasick which of course is not their fault. I would do it again if the water was calmer and my stomach allowed lol

Was this helpful ?

Leslie Haight

June 4, 2025

Trip - Fishing Charters In Cape May NJ | 6 Hour Charter Trip on June 3, 2025

7:00 AM - 1:00 PM

Max 5 guests

Executive team building - The trip was customized to the specific needs of the attendees - Was a great day and caught lots of fish! Thank you!

Was this helpful ?

Chris D.

August 28, 2024

Trip - on August 28, 2024

Took my sons, their girlfriend and my wife out for a 6 hour fishing Charter. The boat is beautiful, extremely clean and well maintained. Capt Mark was so easy to deal with and you felt extremely safe. He knew all the spots and we caught a-lot of fish. His first mate Bob was a retired fireman and worked extremely hard to provide a great time. Just a great all around experience. This is the only charter I would book.

Was this helpful ?

Christopher Boyle

August 26, 2024

Trip - Fishing Charter Cape May NJ | 4 Hour Charter Trip on August 25, 2024

7:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Max 5 guests

Great trip! Caught fish from moment we arrived to fishing grounds until time to leave. Captain Mark and Brian made it fun and easy!!

Was this helpful ?

David Dube

August 24, 2024

Trip - Fishing Charter Cape May NJ | 4 Hour Charter Trip on August 22, 2024

7:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Max 6 guests

Captain Mark found himself without a First Mate, so he had to be both captain and mate. It limited our choices of fish, but we still had a great time reeling in our capacity of bonitos and bluefish. We would book 'Gone Fishing' again.

Was this helpful ?

Will Drexler

July 24, 2024

Trip - on July 24, 2024

Had a great time on Captain Mark’s boat. He was knowledgeable, kind and a pleasure to spend the day with. We did the 4 hour in the afternoon and caught more fish then we could handle. Our group had very little fishing experience and we all had a blast.

Was this helpful ?

Mark C

June 27, 2024

Trip - on June 27, 2024

We had to switch to bay fishing because of the weather, but it turned out to be an awesome day catching tiger sharks with my son!

Was this helpful ?

Cape May Fishing Charter

Cape May Charter Reviews – Real Guest Testimonials for Gone Fishin’ Sport Fishing Charters

At Gone Fishin’ Sport Fishing Charters in Cape May, NJ, our customer reviews speak for themselves. Guests consistently highlight Captain Mark’s professionalism, deep local knowledge, and ability to find fish—from striped bass and flounder on inshore trips to tuna and mahi offshore. Whether it’s a family-friendly fishing experience or a bucket-list offshore adventure, our reviews often mention how fun, easygoing, and memorable the trips were. Many guests return year after year, praising not just the catches but the personalized service that makes every trip feel special.

These testimonials offer firsthand insight into what it’s like to fish Cape May with a trusted, experienced captain. Visitors love the well-equipped boat, the smooth booking process, and the chance to reel in impressive catches while learning from a true pro. If you're searching for top-rated Cape May fishing charters or wondering who to trust for your next saltwater outing, take it from our happy guests—you’re in great hands with Gone Fishin’. Browse the reviews, then get ready to plan a fishing trip worth talking about.